Wednesday, April 18, 2012

Rebuttal to Rebecca Walker's Anti-Feminism

Rebecca Walker
A couple weeks ago, a friend sent me an article called How My Mother's Fanatical Views Tore Us Apart written by Alice Walker's (AW) daughter, Rebecca Walker (RW).  Within the first couple Lines, RW declares that she almost missed out on motherhood due to her mother, AW, being a "rabid feminist."  She states that "feminism has much to answer for denigrating and encouraging women to seek independence whatever the cost to their families."  She describes her mothers idiosyncratic rules about with what toys she was allowed to play and in what games she was allowed to partake.  She details the moments of her life when her mother left her to go around the world, including arranging birth control and her abortion.  She talks about how she "yearned for a traditional mother."  This is just my summary- I definitely encourage you to read it for yourself.

I am messy and a feminist, but it is not feminism which caused my mess.
Whoa.  RW seems to be extremely confused about the difference between being a feminist and being a derelict mother.  After reading this article three different times and in three different attitudes, I simply cannot connect the two from this article.  Feminism does not reject motherhood.  Some brands might now revere the stay-at-home-mom types, but most of the feminists I with which I come in contact think the role of Mom is an exceptional one.  The only restraint feminism puts on children is that one should have them on one's own time- not as dictated by a patriarchal government.  A blessing and an honor-  just maybe not in the bake cookies, sew clothing, change diapers all day route.  They believe in equal parenting.  After reading about RW's trials as a young woman, I think most will agree that her mother was not the ideal, but that is not a symptom of her feminism.
My feminism does not take
away from my love of being
a mom.  
I can speak on my personal journey with feminism, which, in my opinion, has led me to be a much better mom.  My feminism has taught me that Hubby and I can be equal in parenting-  my feminism has led me to Attachment Parenting, which is incredibly hands on.
As far as feminism encouraging women to gain independence regardless of the cost, I refer to a post I wrote a while back Dear Alice Paul, in which I describe the limits of not my feminism but my activism.  Each stage of life offers different measures.
Many anti-feminists wage war against the cause with accusations as such.  It doesn't make sense.  Feminism is not a person.  It is not a thing.  Feminism is not a bad or neglectful mother.   It is a movement, political and social in nature.  It takes shape by the many people who join in.

4 comments:

mkgs said...

I wanted to actually comment on Walker's article, too (which I read once but don't remember very well and therefore need to reread) but I guess I am too tired right now. I'll try and come back to it later, but for now I just want to say: great post. It annoys me when people can't separate personality and individual shortcomings from a life philosophy.

Anonymous said...

Good post!

Activities and beliefs that one partakes in does not necessarily define one's personality.

For example:

I am a supporter of the right to bear arms and carry a weapon with me (I know you may not be making the connection but try to follow me here...).

Supporting the 2nd amendment and carrying a gun will not:

-make you a bad person
-make you a cold blooded or trigger happy killer.
-make you a white male republican.
-make you violent.
-make you gangsta.

Furthermore, it does not make you a bad mom/dad, a bad driver, a bad cook or a bad worker.

Does that mean that bad moms/dads, drivers, cooks and workers don't ever carry weapons? Of course not- that is a silly assumption.

If you are in fact, male republican, gangsta, violent, or a murderer you perhaps might carry a gun, but the fact that you carry does not MAKE you those things; you make yourself those things. Carrying a weapon does not mean that you ARE any of the four.

I am not republican, violent, or a murderer. And I am most definitely not gangsta.

Where is my point?

A bad mother is a bad mother because she is a bad mother- not because she is a feminist. I'm sure there are feminists out there that are bad moms (although probably not many), but they are NOT bad moms because they are feminists. I'd like to believe that ALL feminists are great moms and awesome, well-intentioned people... but we know that isn't the case.

A murderer is a murderer because he/she is a murderer- not because he/she supports the right to bear arms. I'd like to think that all gun supporters are good people that just want to protect themselves and their families. But we know that isn't the case.

Hopefully I didn't veer too far off topic here trying to make my point!

Thanks for this write up!

Anonymous said...

Hi. I am commenting on your post a little late, but the issue is still very interesting. I agree that there is a difference between bad mothering and feminism. You can enjoy Alice Walker's books and her political views even though she may not be a nice person. However, I think her daughter is rejecting how her mother used feminism ideas to justify her behavior. And that is a perversion of feminism. This is a very interesting story that deserves attention.

B McC said...

Interesting assessment. I hadn't thought about it in that light, but I agree with you. I think that it's really important that we choose our actions one by one rather than have a particular choice dictate our actions. Generally speaking. Thanks for joining the conversation!

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...