Monday, November 28, 2011

Thoughts on Abstinence-Only Education

My disclaimer is that I know that my ideas are controversial.

I respectfully say this: Get. Over. It.  


Abstinence Only education is a big thing down here in the south.  The big argument I have heard is "How can you teach kids not to have sex while handing them a condom?"  I have also heard arguments that say schools don't have the time and funding to teach sex education.  Again, cut that garbage out.

Here is my stance:  I think family values are a great thing.  I support not having sex until you are married.  Yay being chaste.  However, family values are just that:  values within a particular family.  NOT society.  Not everyone has the ideal family where sex can be discussed safely.  My aunt is a school nurse, and the other day we had a laugh riot discussing the names given to different sex organs by parents of children.   
All joking aside, it is incredibly important for children starting at a young age to learn the proper names of their anatomy.  Child molestation is real, okay?  I understand you don't want your four-year-old to understand exactly how your marriage bed works, but she needs to be able to tell you exactly how she might have been innappropriately touched. 
I have heard the idea that "If my child needs to know it, I'll teach it."  Well, guess what.  Not all parents will.

In one article I read recently, four types of sex education were described:
1.  No mention of abstinence
2.  Including abstinence in a comprehensive education
3.  Promoting abstinence as the best option
4.  Abstinence until marriage as the only option

You may want to cover your eyes and put your fingers in your ears for what I have to say next.

People (teenagers included) who want to have sex are going to find a way to have sex unless they are taught different values at home.  That is a fact.  I think of sex education as harm reduction.  If you are unfamiliar with the idea of harm reduction, check it out here.

To deny teenagers sex education about how to prevent STDs and unwanted pregnancies is a lot like not teaching someone how to properly use an oven and then getting angry because they got burned. 

Education does not mean that teenagers must go have sex.  In my Organic Chemistry class I learned how to make some deadly compounds, but I haven't set up a lab in my kitchen. 

Often times the same people I hear ranting about not having a comprehensive sex education in schools are usually the same ones ranting about how they don't want to pay for other people's children with welfare.  My solution?  Give them a condom and teach them how to use it.  

Statistics very clearly show that Abstinence-Only education produces the highest percentage of unwanted teen pregnancies.  Wow.  Surprised? 
The lowest percentage of unwanted teen pregnancies are through the education that promotes abstinence as the best option, but not the only option.

I think the disconnect we face is that many people have no tolerance for others who believe differently from themselves.  We must accept that different families have different values.  Maybe chastity is one family's biggest belief.  Maybe not doing heroin is another family's biggest belief. 

Take home message:  Your children are not the only ones who need an education.  All children need a proper education of how their bodies work.  We need to make that available in public schools because we cannot assume it is being taught in private homes. 

7 comments:

Sarah said...

I love your blog, Blythe. I agree with you. I wish all parents did teach their kids what they need to know, but some don't.

My mom was very honest with me about sex and our beliefs and the reality of it all.

And, being married and childless by choice, I'm glad I know about various methods birth control EVEN THOUGH I was abstinent until marriage.

Julia Miller said...

I completely agree with you. I especially like how you really remind us all that we will not use everything we learn (and at the same time it almost makes me throw my homework up into the air and just quit. Just kidding).
My parents never taught me ANYTHING until the fifth grade or up. I don't just mean sex, I mean anything bad at all. I remember in the third grade I was yelling at my peers that the middle finger didn't mean anything and proceeding to flip the bird to everyone and to everything in sight. I had no idea why the heck I got in so much trouble. Even then, they didn’t tell me what it meant, just not to do that “ever again”.
And in the fourth grade everyone was laughing at a nature video when they were talking about sex and I didn’t have a clue of what it was. I actually learned what sex was from porn, well not directly. I Googled “What is sex” and porn came up. Freaked out, I closed it out but eventually the viruses started creeping their way in and my mom had some explaining to do like why those girls were wearing practically nothing and why someone single in my area would want to date a ten year old little girl.
I know its not necessary to tell kids at a young age, but it would have really helped me to have a clue of why everything was bad. I learned curse words and all about drugs from my peers. And by the seventh grade, I found out that my life time self harm of sorts and death wishes upon myself were not healthy. I found out by the news of all things. Not my parents trying to teach me about what happens in the world and why people do what, but learning I was “mental” by the news.
Its not just sex that kids need to learn about by their parents. If my parents had taught me what I REALLY needed/wanted to know and understand, my life would have been so much different. I don’t know if it would have been for the better or worse, but it would have been, well, nice for my parents to tell me these things.
Its not fun to learn about it all on your own. You look to your parents for guidance and try to tell right from wrong by them, but when they are not informing you, you don’t know what the heck to make of any of it. You’re confused. You’re hurt that they didn’t tell you. And if it applies to it, you are so scared you need somebody. But they’re not there. And you don’t know if it is really okay or not since they didn’t/won’t tell you.
This was longer than intended, but I hope you got something out of it.

Christina said...

I really enjoyed reading this, Blythe. Spot on.
I'm just afraid that many people may still "cover their eyes and put their fingers in their ears" too often. I'm not trying to disrespect their values. But in a society, and also within a family (since that is no homogenous, conflict-free space either) open and respectful dialogue has to be possible.
One other thing continues to worry me in many arguments in favor of abstinence: Before or outside of marriage, sex seems to be a dirty and dangerous thing, and that also applies to the people who do it (and enjoy it). Then marriage happens, and all of a sudden the very same act becomes a sanctified, pure and appropriate business. Well, to me there are healthy and fulfilling sexual relationships with or without marriage, and there is "dirt" and "danger" with or without marriage. You can't attribute these judgments to the abstract idea of "having sex" or "having (un-)married sex" themselves. It's always the concrete circumstances, people, behaviors that make it "good" or "bad".
I know I am entering a discursive minefield in referring to her (who I don't entirely agree with), but here's Jessica Valenti's latest book: http://books.google.de/books?id=rQ10AIsHNa4C&printsec=frontcover&hl=de#v=onepage&q&f=false

CBW said...

Very well put- a lot of extremely good points made here.

"...the disconnect we face is that many people have no tolerance for others who believe differently from themselves."

Couldn't have said it any better.

-CBW

Anonymous said...

It is ignorant to believe that abstinence only education is sufficient. Everyone should by now be acutely aware of how well this DOES NOT work, because of all the multi-child families on welfare, teen pregnancies, and rampant STDs. This is not to say that we should promote sex- obviously that is a stupid idea too. However, to educate children and teenagers on how to be safe for "future reference" is a seriously important issue. If you know abstinence does not solve the problem (which clearly we do) then we must fix the problem of STDs and teen pregnancies somehow. Thank you so much for posting this, I agree whole-heartedly.

B McC said...

Christina- I am actually quite excited you mentioned Jessica Valenti because I just ordered Full Frontal Feminism. Thanks for your thoughts and for dropping in.

Kerri said...

I mostly worry about the quality of the curriculum, what exactly they are teaching the kids about different forms of birth control, and when they are teaching the children about it. I will definitely be watching what my kids are learning, and will be sure to teach them our family's views (and others' as well) on pretty much anything they will be learning.

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...